Skip to main content
The South Carolina Forum Home

Abolish Capital Punishment

From "Welcome to The South Carolina Forum!"

Go to the project

The death penalty in South Carolina is both cruel and unusual and has been shown not to be a deterrent to future felonies. Cruelness is demonstrated in the botched executions that have resulted in anything but a swift death and Unusual in that crimes committed in Horry and Richland counties are much, much more likely to result in a capital punishment sentence than elsewhere in the state. Advances in forensic science have resulted in exonerations of a number of wrongly convicted people - a death penalty in final.

Comments(1)

Most recent comments have loaded.
Profile of Evodio T.
Posted by:Evodio T.
2 months ago
I too share a deep moral concern over any unnecessary suffering in executions, we ought not use this method if at all possible. Still, labeling the death penalty 'cruel and unusual' under the Constitution ignores its historical and biblical roots as just retribution for the worst offenses, like premeditated murder. It is not meant primarily as a broad deterrent to all crime, but as society's strongest statement that some acts forfeit the right to live among us and as protection against future harm by the guilty. South Carolina has executed only a handful of individuals even after resuming in 2024, besides getting on death row is already extremely difficult, requiring aggravated circumstances, unanimous jury findings, and years of appeals, which is why exonerations here are very rare (only two in modern history). Geographic differences in charging (e.g., Horry or Richland vs. other counties) reflect local prosecutors, victims' families, and case facts more than systemic unfairness; similar variations exist everywhere and don't make the penalty itself unconstitutional. Today's modern advances in forensics strengthen the system by reducing errors, but for the truly guilty monsters who torture and kill the innocent, final justice through capital punishment upholds the sanctity of innocent life far better than warehousing them at taxpayer expense for decades. We should fix botches through better protocols, not abolish a tool reserved for the most heinous crimes.
  • 1 like

Current status

proposed